Death Classification: Line of Duty Death

Agency: Chicago Police Department

Served: 6 years, 1 month, 24 days

Unit of Assignment / Detail: 2nd Precinct - Madison Street Station

District of Incident (Present Day): 012 - Near West

Location of Occurrence: 

Cause of Death: Gunfire - Friendly (Accidental)

Age at Time of Death: 37


Date of Birth: 23 Sep 1840

Date of Appointment: 11 Oct 1871

Date of Incident: 012 - Near West

End of Watch: 05 Dec 1877

Date of Interment:


Interment Details

 Cemetery: Mount Pleasant Cemetery - Lodi, Wisconsin
 Grave Location: Unknown
 Interment Disposition: Burial


Memorial Details

Superintendent’s Honored Star Case: Not Enshrined

Gold Star Families Memorial Wall: Panel # 20

Illinois Police Officers Memorial Wall: Not Listed

National Law Enforcement Officers Memorial Wall: Not Listed

Officer Down Memorial Page: Listed



 Military Service: Confederate States of America Army


Incident & Biographic Details

Patrolman Gilbert Elliot Reynolds, Star # Unknown, aged 37 years, was a 6 year, 1 month, 24 day veteran of the Chicago Police Department, assigned to the 2nd Precinct – Madison Street Station.

On December 5, 1877, at 6:50 a.m., Officer Reynolds and Patrolman Thomas Brennock were tending to their uniforms prior to the beginning of their shift. The officers were in a room at the rear of the West Madison Street Station located at No. 147 Madison Street (present day 700 West Madison Street). Officer Reynolds was brushing his boots while Officer Brennock brushed his pants. As Officer Brennock put his foot on the bench beside Officer Reynolds, his service revolver fell from his overcoat pocket and struck the floor. Upon striking the floor the pistol discharged and the round struck Patrolman Reynolds in the abdomen, penetrating the base of his left lung. Officer Reynolds fell backwards and exclaimed that he was shot. The City Physician, Doctor Dunne, was immediately summoned to the police station and attended to Officer Reynolds. However, little could be done for him and he died four hours later at 10:30 a.m. He was conscious to the very end all the while repeatedly and emphatically exonerating Officer Brennock from all blame.

Officer Reynolds was waked at his residence located at No. 294 West Van Buren Street (present day 1025 West Van Buren Street). He was laid to rest in Mount Pleasant Cemetery, City of Lodi, Columbia County, Wisconsin.

Patrolman Gilbert Elliot Reynolds, born September 23, 1840, received his Probationary appointment to the Chicago Police Department on October 15, 1871.

Officer Reynolds served in the Confederate States of America Army in the 23rd West Virginia Infantry Battalion, was a veteran of the Civil War (aka War of Rebellion) and was Honorably Discharged. He was survived by his wife; daughter, age 12; parents: Hannah C. (nee Elliot) and Sylvester and siblings: Albert N. and Ida S.

Chicago Police Historical Homicide Database case not found for this incident.